After eight films (including the meta-horror of Wes Craven’s New Nightmare) and nearly 20 decades, Robert Englund wore the razor glove for the final time. But in keeping with the history of A Nightmare on Elm Street, Freddy Krueger’s curtain call wasn’t what anyone expected it would be.

Clare Brunton of W-Rated helps us close down this mega-series with 2003’s horror monster mash-up Freddy vs. Jason. We’ll discuss how the movie deftly combines the Elm Street films with Friday the 13th, whether its lack of intense scares detracts from the film, and the missed sequel opportunities.

Directed by Ronny Yu, Freddy vs. Jason might not be considered a cinematic turning point at large, but the film did unite two of horror’s biggest bads just before their respective series faced the reboot treatment. So choose your fighter, and secure ringside seats to the ultimate horror showdown.