After exploring time travel and creating a shared universe with X-Men: Days of Future Past, where could the sequel go next? Why, the gods, of course! For better or worse, 2016’s X-Men: Apocalypse pits the Marvel mutants against their most formidable enemy yet: a big, blue Oscar Isaac.

In this episode, Clare Brunton of W-Rated helps us uncover the truth behind director Bryan Singer’s most divisive X-Men installment. We’ll discuss whether the movie is actually unjustly hated, how it serves as a prequel to Singer’s original trilogy, and whether Isaac’s performance hurts or helps.

Join us as we journey back to the Apocalypse and decide whether the movie lives up to its name. Is this where the X-Films finally jumped the shark?